Gibbs' Reflective Cycle: The 6 Stages

Q: What Are the 6 Stages of Gibbs' Reflective Cycle?

The six stages are: 1. Description: Record what happened objectively, 2. Feelings: Explore emotional responses, 3. Evaluation: Assess what worked and what didn't, 4. Analysis: Make sense of the situation, 5. Conclusion: Identify key learning points, and 6. Action Plan: Create specific steps for improvement.

Q: When Should I Use Gibbs' Reflective Cycle?

The cycle is useful for reflecting on significant incidents, challenging situations, successful experiences, and professional development opportunities. It proves most valuable when used consistently.

Q: How Can I Find Time for Reflection in a Busy Setting?

Build reflection into existing routines, such as using quiet times during the day, incorporating reflections into documentation, or scheduling brief weekly reflection periods.

Q: What Makes Gibbs' Cycle Different from Other Reflection Models?

Gibbs' cycle focuses on feelings, separates evaluation and analysis, and includes a clear action planning stage, making it suitable for practitioners in people-focused professions.

Q: How Do I Know if My Reflections Are Deep Enough?

Strong reflections go beyond simple description, consider multiple perspectives, link to theory and research, lead to specific improvements, and show clear learning outcomes.

Q: How Can I Use Gibbs' Cycle for Team Reflection?

Team reflection benefits from shared language, clear structure, collaborative learning, and consistent practice improvements.

Q: What Common Mistakes Should I Avoid When Using the Cycle?

Avoid mixing description with analysis, skipping the feelings stage, creating vague action plans, rushing through stages, and failing to implement changes.

Q: How Can I Make Sure My Reflections Lead to Real Changes?

Focus on implementation by creating specific, measurable action plans, setting realistic timeframes, reviewing and revising regularly, and documenting changes in practice.

A Comprehensive Guide for Students and Early Years Professionals

Every day in an Early Years setting there are moments worth examining. A child masters building blocks after weeks of trying. A challenging conversation ends in unexpected understanding. A team meeting generates fresh insights into supporting behaviour.

These moments contain valuable lessons, but their teaching potential often slips away without a structured way to examine and analyse them.

This is where Gibbs’ Reflective Cycle proves invaluable. Developed in 1988, this practical framework helps Early Years professionals and educators extract meaningful insights from daily experiences. The model guides practitioners and educators through 6 clear stages: description, feelings, evaluation, analysis, conclusion, and action planning.

Why This Matters Now

Early Years settings face increasing demands for quality improvement, professional development, and evidence-based practice. Reflection supports all three. Research shows practitioners who reflect systematically:

Make more informed decisions about children’s learning
Build stronger partnerships with families
Develop more effective team practices

What You’ll Learn

This comprehensive guide unpacks Gibbs’ cycle for all interested, with additional information specifically for Early Years practice. Through real examples from nursery settings, you’ll discover:

How to apply each stage of the cycle effectively
Practical strategies for finding reflection time in busy days
Ways to use reflection for professional development
Methods for improving outcomes for children

Practical Applications

The guide includes specific tools for:

Reflecting on child observations
Improving response to behaviours that challenge us
Strengthening parent partnerships
Enhancing team collaboration
Supporting professional development

Early Years work demands both heart and mind. Gibbs’ cycle helps you use both effectively, turning daily experiences into professional growth. Whether you’re new to reflection or looking to deepen your practice, this guide provides the structure and support you need.

Let’s explore how systematic reflection can enhance your practice and improve outcomes for the children in your care.

Download this Article as a PDF

Download this article as a PDF so you can revisit it whenever you want. We’ll email you a download link.

You’ll also get notification of our FREE Early Years TV videos each week.

Get your PDF Download and FREE Early Years TV Updates

Introduction

Picture yourself at the end of a busy day in your Early Years setting. A child had a difficult transition at drop-off, another made unexpected progress with their drawing, and your team handled a challenging parent conversation. Each of these moments holds valuable insights for your professional growth—but how do you capture and learn from them effectively?

This is where Gibbs’ Reflective Cycle comes in. Developed by Graham Gibbs in 1988, this structured approach to reflection has become a cornerstone of professional development in education and care settings (Gibbs, 1988). The model offers a clear, systematic way to process your daily experiences and transform them into meaningful learning opportunities.

Why Reflection Matters in Early Years

Early Years practitioners make countless decisions daily, often in complex situations involving young children, families, and colleagues. Research found that reflective practice encouraged self-awareness and the ability to navigate complex ethical and moral challenges in clinical settings (Rich & Parker, 1995). This is particularly crucial in Early Years settings, where our actions directly impact children’s development and wellbeing.

Understanding the Basics

At its heart, Gibbs’ Reflective Cycle guides you through six stages of reflection:

Description: What happened?
Feelings: What were you thinking and feeling?
Evaluation: What was good and challenging?
Analysis: What sense can you make of it?
Conclusion: What else could you have done?
Action Plan: What will you do next time?

Each stage builds upon the previous one, creating a comprehensive framework that helps you extract maximum learning from your experiences. As Atkins and Murphy (1993) note for any reflective practice: a detailed examination of feelings, knowledge, and assumptions helps explore alternatives and generate insights.

The Value for Early Years Practitioners

For those working in Early Years settings of all types, reflection isn’t just about professional development—it’s about enhancing the quality of care and education we provide. When we reflect effectively, we:

Improve our practice through systematic learning from experience
Develop more consistent and thoughtful approaches to challenging situations
Build stronger relationships with children, families, and colleagues
Meet professional standards and requirements more confidently

Understanding Gibbs’ Reflective Cycle

The Foundation of the Model

Gibbs’ Reflective Cycle emerged from a simple yet powerful idea: that we learn best when we think carefully about our experiences. Graham Gibbs developed this model in 1988 as part of his work on learning by doing, recognising that professionals needed a clear structure to help them learn from their daily experiences (Gibbs, 1988).

How the Model Works

Think of Gibbs’ cycle as a journey through six connected stages. Unlike linear models that move from start to finish, this cycle encourages you to revisit experiences and continuously build upon your learning. A cyclical approach to reflection may particularly suit Early Years settings, where similar situations often arise with different children or families.

The 6 Stages

Description Stage
- Creates a clear picture of what happened
- Focuses on facts rather than interpretations
- Answers: What? When? Where? Who? What happened?
Feelings Stage
- Explores emotional responses
- Acknowledges the impact of feelings on actions
- Considers both immediate and later reactions
Evaluation Stage
- Weighs up what worked and what didn’t
- Looks at the experience objectively
- Considers multiple perspectives
Analysis Stage
- Makes sense of the situation
- Links practice with theory
- Explores why things happened as they did
Conclusion Stage
- Draws learning points from the experience
- Identifies what could have been done differently
- Synthesises insights for future practice
Action Plan Stage
- Creates specific steps for future situations
- Develops concrete strategies
- Sets clear, achievable goals

The 6 Stages of Gibbs’ Reflective Cycle in Detail

Description Stage: Setting the Scene

The description stage creates the foundation for reflection by establishing what actually happened. As Stuart (1998) emphasises, this stage requires pure description without analysis or judgment – like a camera capturing a moment in time, described via Kolb’s diagram as ‘Concrete Experience’.

Your task here is to record the key facts: what happened, who was involved, when and where it occurred, and what the outcome was. For example, in an Early Years setting, you might describe a child’s behaviour during circle time, noting exactly what happened without interpreting why.

Keep your description clear and focused. Avoid the common pitfall of mixing in analysis or emotions at this stage – there’s time for that later. Description involves the ability to recognise and recollect accurately salient events and key features of an experience
and to give a comprehensive account of the situation (Boud et al 1985).

Feelings Stage: Exploring Emotional Responses

The feelings stage acknowledges that emotions influence our actions and learning. Here, you explore your feelings during and after the experience. Gibbs (1988) specifically included this stage because emotions significantly impact how we handle situations, which is especially applicable in Early Years work.

Consider both your immediate reactions and feelings that emerged later. Be honest about your emotions, but maintain professional language. For instance, instead of writing “I was furious,” you might say, “I felt very frustrated when…”

It is also worth considering others’ feelings too – how might the children, parents, or colleagues involved have felt? This builds empathy and a broader understanding of the situation.

Evaluation Stage: Weighing Up What Happened

In the evaluation stage, you assess what went well and what didn’t. You could look at the experience objectively, considering both positive and negative aspects. This balanced approach helps avoid focusing solely on problems.

Consider aspects like:

What worked effectively?
What didn’t work as planned?
What helped or hindered the situation?

Keep your evaluation balanced and specific. Rather than saying “everything went wrong,” identify the particular elements that succeeded or needed improvement.

Analysis Stage: Making Sense of the Situation

The analysis stage moves beyond simple evaluation to understand why things happened as they did. Here, you connect practice with theory and look for patterns or explanations. As Haddock (1997) explains, analysis and learning are where you can become freed from ritualistic practice, to become an autonomous, responsible, mature and confident practitioner.

You need to draw on your professional knowledge and any relevant theories or research, both from the Early Years sector and more widely accepted research. For example, you might consider how child development theory explains a particular behaviour, or how communication models illuminate a challenging parent interaction.

Conclusion Stage: Learning from the Experience

The conclusion stage pulls together your insights from previous stages to identify key learning points. Stuart (1998) mentions reflection fosters emotional awareness and a willingness to challenge one’s beliefs, promoting personal growth.

Focus on what you’ve learned and what you might do differently next time. Be specific about your insights – avoid vague conclusions like “I need to do better” in favour of concrete learning points. For example, you might consider doing a training course about schematic play and how this supports child development.

Action Plan Stage: Planning for the Future

The final stage transforms your insights into specific actions for future practice. Effective action plans should be specific, achievable, and relevant to your practice.

Create clear, practical steps you can take to improve similar situations in future. For example, rather than “improve communication with parents,” specify “introduce weekly email updates about children’s activities.”

Remember that the cycle is continuous – your action plan leads to new experiences, which begin the reflection process again.

Why Cyclical Reflection Matters

The cycle’s circular nature serves a crucial purpose. This approach may help practitioners:

Build connections between different experiences
Develop deeper understanding over time
Apply learning to new situations
Continuously improve their practice

Key Principles of the Model

Several core principles underpin Gibbs’ model:

Structured Yet Flexible

While the cycle provides a clear structure, you can adapt it to suit different situations. For example, when reflecting on a quick interaction with a parent, you might move through the stages more briefly than when considering a complex safeguarding situation.

Experience-Based Learning

The model recognises that some of our most valuable learning comes from real experiences. This makes it particularly relevant for Early Years practitioners, who face unique situations daily.

Integration of Feelings

Unlike some reflection models, Gibbs explicitly acknowledges the role of emotions. This is especially important in Early Years work, where emotional intelligence plays a crucial role in effective, quality practice.

Action-Oriented

The cycle doesn’t stop at understanding—it leads to concrete changes in practice. This practical focus helps ensure that reflection leads to real improvements in your work with children and families.

Making It Work in Practice

To use the model effectively in Early Years settings:

Start with recent experiences while they’re fresh in your mind
Use simple language that feels natural to you
Focus on situations that matter to your practice
Keep notes in a way that works for you (written, audio, or digital)
Set aside regular time for reflection, even if brief
Share reflections with colleagues when appropriate

The model’s strength lies in its adaptability to different situations while maintaining a consistent approach to learning from experience. Whether you’re reflecting on child observations, team interactions, or parent partnerships, the same basic structure helps you extract meaningful insights and improve your practice.

Benefits and Applications

Enhanced Learning from Experience

In Early Years settings, every day brings new experiences and learning opportunities. Gibbs’ Reflective Cycle helps you make the most of these moments, transforming daily challenges into valuable learning experiences. As Atkins and Murphy (1993) highlight, structured reflection helps practitioners move beyond simple recall to deeper understanding of their practice.

When practitioners engage with the cycle regularly, they develop better understanding of children’s behaviour patterns and improve their responses to challenging situations. This systematic approach to reflection naturally leads to more effective communication with parents and an enhanced ability to spot development opportunities in everyday moments.

Professional Development

Regular use of Gibbs’ cycle supports continuous professional development, a key requirement for Early Years practitioners. Research across numerous sectors has shown that systematic reflection helps practitioners build a stronger professional identity and develop more consistent approaches to practice. This becomes particularly valuable when meeting professional standards and creating meaningful development records.

The cycle provides a framework for documenting your professional journey and identifying training needs. During supervision meetings, having detailed reflections helps demonstrate your growth and understanding. This structured approach to reflection proves especially valuable when building evidence for qualifications or preparing for career advancement.

Personal Growth

Beyond professional benefits, Gibbs’ model supports significant personal development. Rich and Parker (1995) note that regular reflection helps build moral reasoning, empathy, and resilience. This becomes particularly important in Early Years settings, where emotional demands can be high and stress management is crucial.

The structured approach builds confidence in professional judgment and helps practitioners handle difficult conversations more effectively. As you reflect systematically on your experiences, you may notice increased job satisfaction and greater security in your practice decisions.

Decision-Making Improvement

In Early Years work, quick decisions often have lasting impacts. Stuart (1998) suggests by critically analysing experiences, professionals make more thoughtful and less impulsive decisions. This proves particularly valuable when making safeguarding decisions or planning interventions.

Through regular reflection, practitioners develop more consistent responses to behaviour and create better-planned activities. The cycle helps you understand the impact of your decisions more clearly, leading to improved resource management and more effective classroom organisation.

Critical Thinking Development

The cycle naturally builds critical thinking skills, which are crucial for Early Years practice. Practitioners who regularly use the model develop a deeper understanding of child development and better assessment of learning opportunities. This enhanced analytical ability shows itself in more thorough evaluation of activities and improved problem-solving abilities.

Consider how this works in practice: when reviewing child observations, practitioners using Gibbs’ cycle tend to notice patterns and make connections they might otherwise miss. Their activity planning becomes more meaningful because they’re drawing on detailed reflections of what has worked before and why.

Real-World Applications

The practical value of Gibbs’ cycle becomes clear in everyday situations. When managing behaviour that challenges us, for instance, practitioners move beyond simply reacting to understanding the situation fully. They document what happened clearly, understand their emotional responses, and create specific plans for future incidents.

Similarly, when working on parent partnerships, the cycle helps practitioners analyse their communication methods more effectively. They can evaluate different approaches to family engagement and develop more successful strategies based on careful reflection of what works best.

Making It Work in Practice

To gain these benefits in your setting, start by incorporating reflection into your daily routine in manageable ways. The value comes not from perfectly following every step, but from making reflection a natural part of your professional practice. Share insights with colleagues when appropriate, and keep records in a way that suits your working style.

Remember that reflection shouldn’t feel like an extra task on your already full plate. Instead, it should become an integral part of how you process and learn from your experiences, ultimately making your work more effective and satisfying.

The structured nature of Gibbs’ cycle helps ensure that your reflections lead to concrete improvements in practice. Whether you’re considering a quick interaction or analysing a complex situation, the framework helps you extract meaningful insights that enhance your work with children and families.

Special Focus: Early Years Practice

Adapting the Cycle for Early Years Settings

The dynamic nature of Early Years settings presents unique opportunities for reflection. Early Years practitioners face distinctive challenges that require thoughtful adaptation of Gibbs’ cycle to their specific context. In nursery environments, situations often unfold quickly and require immediate response. You might find yourself managing a child’s emotional outburst while simultaneously considering the needs of other children and communicating with parents. This complexity makes structured reflection particularly valuable.

Key Areas for Early Years Reflection

In Early Years practice, reflection takes on special significance when considering child development and learning. When observing children’s progress, the cycle helps you capture subtle yet significant moments that might otherwise be missed. For instance, a simple observation of a child’s mark-making becomes richer when viewed through the lens of structured reflection. Detailed observations, when reflected upon systematically, inform more effective planning for individual children.

Parent partnerships benefit significantly from regular reflection. Consider the common scenario of discussing development concerns during parents’ evening. Using Gibbs’ cycle helps you prepare more effectively by reflecting on previous conversations, considering the parents’ perspective, and planning your approach thoughtfully. This structured reflection often leads to more productive and positive parent interactions.

Team collaboration strengthens through systematic reflection. When Early Years teams use the cycle together, they develop more consistent approaches to behaviour management and share deeper insights about children’s progress. This collaborative reflection helps build a shared understanding of effective practice and strengthens safeguarding procedures.

Practical Applications

Consider how the cycle works in managing behaviours that challenge us. Rather than simply reacting to situations, practitioners can use structured reflection to understand patterns and develop more effective responses. For example, when reflecting on a difficult storytime session, you might move from simple description of events to understanding underlying causes and planning specific improvements.

Supporting transitions provides another valuable opportunity for applying the cycle. When helping children settle into nursery, structured reflection helps practitioners understand individual children’s responses to separation, evaluate settling-in procedures, and improve parent communication during this sensitive time.

You may use the cycle when assessing key developmental stages. A simple observation of a child’s writing skills becomes more meaningful when reflected upon systematically, leading to deeper understanding of their development and clearer planning for next steps.

Implementation in Practice

To make reflection work effectively in your setting, start with brief, focused reflections on specific incidents. Even five minutes of structured reflection can provide valuable insights. The key is to make reflection manageable within your busy schedule while maintaining its value as a learning tool.

Creating a reflective culture within your setting doesn’t happen overnight. Start by incorporating reflection into existing meetings and supervision sessions. Share insights with colleagues and encourage paired reflection when appropriate. The goal is to make reflection a natural part of your professional practice rather than an additional burden.

Remember, as Atkins and Murphy (1993) emphasise, the reflection process culminates in a changed understanding or perspective. In the Early Years, this reflection should support, not hinder, your primary focus on the children. Keep your reflections focused and relevant to improving practice and outcomes for children and families. When used effectively, Gibbs’ cycle becomes a valuable tool for professional development and improved practice, rather than just another task to complete.

Through regular use of the cycle, Early Years practitioners often find they develop deeper insights into children’s learning, more effective partnerships with parents, and stronger professional relationships within their teams. This systematic approach to reflection helps transform daily experiences into valuable learning opportunities that benefit both practitioners and the children in their care.

Implementation Guidelines

Getting Started with Reflection

Beginning a structured reflection practice might seem daunting amid the busy atmosphere of an Early Years setting. However, successful implementation starts with small, manageable steps rather than dramatic changes to your routine.

Start by identifying natural pause points in your day. This might be during children’s nap time, after the morning session, or during your planning time. Consistent timing helps establish reflection as a regular habit, making it feel less like an extra task and more like a natural part of your professional practice.

Consider keeping a simple notebook dedicated to reflection, or use your setting’s digital documentation system if available. The key is finding a method that feels comfortable and sustainable for you. As Rich and Parker (1995) note, incorporating structured guidance for reflection and critical analysis minimises risks and ensures ethical use.

Creating Sustainable Routines

Building reflection into your existing routines proves more successful than trying to create entirely new ones. For instance, you might add five minutes of structured reflection to your end-of-day documentation, or incorporate it into your weekly planning sessions. Haddock (1997) suggested that it should be the practitioners that reflect on actions to bring about meaningful change and long-term sustainability instead of infrequent reviews from managers or scholars.

When working with colleagues, consider how reflection can enhance rather than burden team meetings. You might begin each staff meeting with a brief shared reflection on the week’s significant moments, using Gibbs’ cycle to structure the discussion. This approach helps build a reflective culture while making efficient use of limited time.

Managing Time Effectively

Time constraints often present the biggest challenge to regular reflection. Effective reflection doesn’t always require lengthy sessions. A focused five-minute reflection on a specific incident often proves more valuable than an hour of unfocused thinking.

Develop the habit of ‘micro-reflections’ throughout your day. For example, take two minutes after a challenging interaction to note down key points using the cycle’s structure. These brief reflections can accumulate into valuable insights over time.

Overcoming Common Challenges

Maintaining Objectivity

One common challenge involves maintaining objectivity, particularly when reflecting on emotional situations. Stepping back from the immediate emotional response by focusing first on the description stage of the cycle. Only move to analysing feelings once you’ve established a clear, factual account of events.

When dealing with challenging situations, consider using these strategies:

Write your initial description, then revisit it after a short break
Share your reflection with a trusted colleague for perspective
Focus on specific, observable behaviours rather than interpretations

Managing Difficult Reflections

Some experiences prove particularly challenging to reflect upon, especially those involving sensitive issues or unsuccessful outcomes. In these cases, Gibbs (1988) emphasises the importance of maintaining a learning mindset rather than focusing on fault-finding.

Remember that difficult reflections often provide the richest learning opportunities. When facing a challenging reflection:

Break the experience into smaller, manageable parts
Focus on aspects you can influence or change
Seek support from mentors or supervisors when needed

Building Long-term Habits

Successful reflection becomes easier with practice. Start with simpler reflections on straightforward situations before tackling more complex issues. As your confidence grows, you’ll find the cycle becomes more natural and intuitive.

Focus on making your reflection practice:

Realistic within your time constraints
Relevant to your daily work
Sustainable over the long term
Valuable for your professional development

Remember, the goal isn’t perfect reflection but consistent, meaningful engagement with your professional experiences. Through regular practice, reflection becomes an invaluable tool for professional growth rather than an administrative burden.

Over time, you’ll likely find that structured reflection enhances rather than hinders your work with children and families. It provides the space to process experiences, learn from challenges, and continually improve your practice in ways that benefit everyone in your setting.

Advanced Applications

Integration with Other Reflective Models

Understanding how Gibbs’ Reflective Cycle works alongside other reflection models can enhance your professional practice. As Rich and Parker (1995) note, while Gibbs’ model is popular due to its simplicity and accessibility, alternative models like those by Johns or Schön may be more suitable for exploring complex ethical dilemmas or fostering advanced critical thinking skills.

Kolb’s Learning Cycle shares important similarities with Gibbs’ model. Both emphasise the importance of learning from experience, but Kolb focuses more on how we transform experience into knowledge. While Gibbs guides you through specific stages of reflection, Kolb helps you understand how you learn from these reflections. Combining both approaches can strengthen your professional development.

Schön’s concepts of reflection-in-action and reflection-on-action add another valuable dimension. As Schön explains, reflection-in-action involves thinking on your feet during situations, while reflection-on-action involves looking back at events afterwards. Gibbs’ cycle naturally supports reflection-on-action, but you can also use elements of it to prepare for reflection-in-action, particularly in common Early Years scenarios like managing behaviour or supporting transitions.

Practical Integration in Early Years Settings

Consider how these models work together in practice. When managing a behaviour that challenges us, you might:

Use reflection-in-action to make immediate decisions
Apply Gibbs’ cycle afterwards for detailed reflection
Consider how the experience fits into Kolb’s learning cycle for future planning

This integrated approach helps practitioners develop more nuanced understanding of their practice. It’s not about rigidly following multiple models, but rather drawing on different approaches to enhance your reflection.

Digital Tools and Documentation

The digital age offers new opportunities for reflection. It’s important to find tools that support rather than complicate the reflection process. Many Early Years settings use digital learning journals and observation tools that can also support reflection.

When choosing digital tools, consider how they can:

Streamline your reflection process
Link observations with reflections
Support team collaboration
Maintain confidentiality
Provide easy access to past reflections

Making Technology Work for You

Digital platforms can enhance your reflective practice in several ways. For instance, many learning journal apps now include specific sections for practitioner reflection. These tools often allow you to:

Link reflections directly to observations of children’s learning
Share appropriate reflections with colleagues for feedback
Track patterns in your practice over time
Access your reflections easily for supervision and professional development discussions

However, it is worth noting that technology shouldn’t drive your reflection process. The tool should support, not dictate, your reflection. Choose platforms that feel intuitive and align with your setting’s existing systems.

Building a Digital Reflection Portfolio

Creating a digital reflection portfolio can help you track your professional growth. Consider including:

Regular reflections on key incidents
Links to relevant theory and research
Evidence of how reflection has improved your practice
Plans for future professional development

Looking to the Future

As technology continues to evolve, new tools for reflection will emerge. Effective reflective practice may depend more on the practitioner’s commitment to learning than on specific tools or frameworks.

Remember that whether you’re using paper and pen or the latest digital platform, the key principles of reflection remain the same:

Regular engagement with experiences
Honest examination of practice
Commitment to improvement
Focus on outcomes for children

The most effective approach often combines traditional and digital methods, using each where it adds most value.

When integrating different models and tools, focus on what helps you reflect most effectively. Your approach might combine elements from various models while using both digital and traditional documentation methods. The key is developing a sustainable system that supports your professional growth and enhances your practice with children and families.

Assessment and Quality

Evaluating Your Reflective Practice

The quality of reflection directly impacts its value for professional development. As Atkins and Murphy (1993) emphasise, a detailed examination of feelings, knowledge, and assumptions is needed to explore alternatives and generate insights. This process culminates in a changed understanding or perspective. In Early Years settings, where practice constantly evolves, the ability to assess and improve your reflective practice becomes particularly important.

Quality reflection shows certain key characteristics. Rich and Parker (1995) identify several indicators of depth in reflection:

Clear links between experience and learning
Evidence of critical thinking
Consideration of multiple perspectives
Connection to relevant theory
Specific plans for improvement

When reviewing your reflections, consider whether they move beyond simple descriptions to explore the deeper implications of your experiences. Maybe ask yourself: “Has this reflection changed my understanding or approach to practice?”

Developing Deeper Reflection

Moving from surface-level to deeper reflection takes practice. Quality reflection in Early Years settings should:

Consider the broader context of children’s development and learning
Examine assumptions about practice
Question established routines when appropriate
Link daily experiences to professional knowledge
Lead to specific improvements in practice

Using Reflection for Professional Growth

Your reflections form a valuable record of professional development. Systematic reflection provides evidence of growth that proves particularly valuable during supervision and career planning discussions.

When building your professional portfolio, select reflections that demonstrate:

Your development over time
Response to challenges
Implementation of learning
Impact on children’s outcomes
Growth in professional understanding

Making Reflection Count

Quality reflection directly supports career development. Consider how your reflections can:

Support supervision discussions by providing concrete examples of your practice
Demonstrate professional growth when applying for new positions
Identify areas for further training and development
Show evidence of meeting professional standards
Guide your continuous professional development

Building a Professional Portfolio

Your collection of reflections becomes a powerful tool for professional development. Organising reflections to show progression in key areas:

Professional knowledge and understanding
Practical skills and abilities
Relationships with children and families
Team working and leadership
Professional values and commitments

Moving Forward

Regular review of your reflections helps identify patterns and areas for development. Consider setting aside time each month to:

Review recent reflections for common themes
Identify areas where you’ve grown
Spot gaps in your knowledge or skills
Plan next steps for development
Celebrate progress and achievements

Supporting Continuous Improvement

Quality reflection leads naturally to continuous improvement. Effective reflection will often connect to future practice, it may drive future actions. When planning your professional development:

Use your reflections to identify learning needs
Set specific goals based on reflection insights
Seek opportunities to address identified gaps
Review progress regularly
Adjust plans based on new learning

Maintaining Momentum

Sustaining quality reflection takes commitment. Ask yourself:

Are my reflections leading to meaningful changes in practice?
Do I consider multiple perspectives when reflecting?
Am I making connections between theory and practice?
Does my reflection support children’s outcomes?
How can I deepen my reflective practice?

The goal isn’t perfect reflection but continuous improvement. Focus on making each reflection count, using the insights gained to enhance your practice and support better outcomes for the children in your care.

Case Studies and Examples

Professional Applications Across Sectors

Real-world examples help illustrate how Gibbs’ cycle works in practice. From the research by Rich and Parker (1995), we understand that certain models may be best in certain circumstances or we may see how different professionals adapt the model to their specific contexts.

Healthcare Example: Student Midwife’s Experience

A compelling example shows a student midwife reflecting on supporting a mother during labour. The student initially struggled with providing emotional support when the mother’s birth plan needed to change from natural birth to requiring an epidural.

Following Gibbs’ cycle, the reflection revealed:

Description: The mother’s labour was protracted, requiring a change in pain management approach.

Feelings: The student felt inadequate in providing emotional support and struggled with confidence.

Evaluation: While medical care remained good, emotional support could have been better.

Analysis: The student identified that focusing too much on clinical tasks prevented recognition of emotional needs.

Conclusion: Better preparation for supporting women through changed birth plans was needed.

Action Plan: The student planned to develop better emotional support strategies and communication skills.

Early Years Specific Cases

Supporting Breastfeeding Mothers

Another documented example shows a midwife using Gibbs’ cycle to reflect on supporting a first-time mother struggling with breastfeeding. The reflection followed this structure:

Description: “A first-time mother was struggling to breastfeed her newborn. The baby was crying inconsolably, and the mother showed visible distress.”

Feelings: The midwife experienced anxiety watching the mother’s distress but felt relief when able to offer practical support.

Evaluation: The introduction of a nipple shield proved successful, though earlier intervention might have helped.

Analysis: Technical knowledge combined with emotional support proved crucial.

Action Plan: Development of more proactive support strategies for future similar situations.

Early Years Setting Examples

Managing Behaviours That Challenge Us

An example of a practitioner reflecting on managing group behaviour during storytime could be:

Description: Several children became disruptive during the session, affecting the whole group’s engagement.

Feelings: The practitioner felt frustrated and concerned about maintaining other children’s interest.

Evaluation: Some management strategies worked briefly but weren’t sustainable.

Analysis: The timing of the session and group size may have contributed to the challenges.

Conclusion: Smaller group sizes and different timing might work better.

Action Plan: Implement changes to group size and timing, with clear behaviour expectations.

Parent Partnership Development

Another case of improving parent communication could be:

Description: A practitioner struggled to communicate development concerns to a parent during an evening meeting.

Feelings: Anxiety about maintaining a positive relationship while sharing concerns.

Evaluation: The conversation proved more positive than anticipated, though preparation could have been better.

Analysis: Preparation and timing of the conversation significantly impacted its success.

Conclusion: Better preparation helps difficult conversations go more smoothly.

Action Plan: Develop a framework for preparing for challenging conversations with parents.

Team Collaboration Case

An example of reflecting on team coordination:

Description: Team members had different approaches to settling children at naptime.

Feelings: Staff felt frustrated by inconsistent approaches.

Evaluation: Children showed confusion due to varying approaches.

Analysis: Lack of team communication led to inconsistency.

Conclusion: Need for agreed approach and better communication.

Action Plan: Develop consistent settling procedures through team discussion.

These examples demonstrate how Gibbs’ cycle adapts to different situations while maintaining its structured approach to learning from experience. Each shows how systematic reflection leads to practical improvements in professional practice.

Conclusion

Key Insights for Early Years Practice

Gibbs’ Reflective Cycle provides Early Years practitioners with a structured approach to learning from experience. As Atkins and Murphy (1993) suggest, it is evident that reflection, as a learning tool, is a necessary process in professional education. Practice is central to education. If learning is to occur from practice, then reflection is vital (Benner 1984, Champion 1991). The evidence throughout this exploration confirms three essential points about reflection in Early Years settings:

Reflection enhances practice. Regular, structured reflection leads to improved decision-making, stronger parent partnerships, and more effective team collaboration. The cycle’s systematic approach turns daily experiences into valuable learning opportunities.

Structure supports success. The six-stage framework gives practitioners clear direction for reflection. This structure, as Rich and Parker (1995) note, helps practitioners move beyond surface-level thinking to deeper professional insights.

Practice creates progress. Regular engagement with reflection builds professional confidence and competence. Practitioners who maintain consistent reflective practice may show measurable improvements in their professional effectiveness.

Practical Implementation

Early Years practitioners succeed with Gibbs’ cycle when they:

Start small with focused reflections on specific incidents
Build reflection into existing routines
Share insights with colleagues
Link reflections to children’s outcomes
Use reflection to inform planning

Future Developments

The future of reflective practice in Early Years settings could include the following trends:

Digital integration continues to offer new opportunities for documenting and sharing reflections. Technology will increasingly support collaborative reflection among Early Years teams, whether that’s small changes like digital diaries and records, or larger changes like guidance and frameworks from apps.

Professional requirements increasingly emphasise the importance of reflective practice. Evidence of systematic reflection becomes more central to professional development and career progression.

Final Recommendations

For Early Years practitioners starting or developing their reflective practice:

Begin with basics:

Choose one situation each day for focused reflection
Follow the six stages in order
Keep initial reflections brief but regular

Build sustainable habits:

Link reflection to daily documentation
Use quiet times for quick reflections
Create simple templates that work for you

Develop your practice:

Share reflections with trusted colleagues
Connect reflections to professional goals
Review and revise your approach regularly

Moving Forward

Chesney’s (1996) research confirms that reflection and critical analysis of clinical incidents is therapeutic and potentiates learning from practice, linking practice with theory; and critical analysis generates options and possibilities, discriminates intelligently and can identify new ideas. Therefore, Early Years practitioners may benefit most when they:

Focus on impact:

Consider how reflection improves outcomes for children
Track changes in practice resulting from reflection
Document improvements in professional confidence

Maintain momentum:

Set realistic goals for regular reflection
Celebrate small successes
Build on existing strengths

Support others:

Share effective reflection strategies
Encourage team reflection
Create supportive reflection environments

The evidence shows that Gibbs’ Reflective Cycle offers Early Years practitioners a practical, effective framework for professional growth. Through consistent application, reflection becomes an integral part of practice rather than an additional task. This integration supports continuous improvement in the quality of care and education provided to young children.

Remember: effective reflection serves children’s needs first. Your reflective practice directly enhances the quality of Early Years provision and supports better outcomes for the children in your care.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is the Gibbs Cycle of Reflection?

Gibbs’ Reflective Cycle, developed by Graham Gibbs in 1988, provides a structured framework for learning from experiences through reflection. As Gibbs (1988) explains, it guides practitioners through six stages of reflection: Description, Feelings, Evaluation, Analysis, Conclusion, and Action Plan.

The cycle differs from other reflection models by explicitly acknowledging emotions and separating evaluation from analysis. This structure, according to Rich and Parker (1995), makes it particularly useful for reflecting on everyday tasks or situations that are not overly complex or ethically charged.

What Are the 6 Stages of Gibbs’ Reflective Cycle?

The six stages follow a logical progression:

1. Description: Record what happened objectively
2. Feelings: Explore emotional responses
3. Evaluation: Assess what worked and what didn’t
4. Analysis: Make sense of the situation
5. Conclusion: Identify key learning points
6. Action Plan: Create specific steps for improvement

Each stage builds upon the previous ones, creating a comprehensive framework for learning from experience.

How Do I Write a Good Reflection Using Gibbs’ Cycle?

Effective reflection using Gibbs’ cycle requires attention to each stage…

Start with clear description:

Focus on facts rather than interpretation
Include relevant context
Keep to the specific incident

Move through each stage systematically:

Address emotions honestly but professionally
Link theory to practice in analysis
Create specific, achievable action plans

When Should I Use Gibbs’ Reflective Cycle?

You could use the cycle for:

Regular reflection on:

Significant incidents
Challenging situations
Successful experiences
Professional development opportunities

The cycle proves most valuable when used consistently rather than only for major events.

How Can I Find Time for Reflection in a Busy Setting?

Time management concerns appear frequently in practitioner questions. Practical solutions include:

Build reflection into existing routines:

Use quiet times during the day
Incorporate brief reflections into documentation
Schedule short reflection periods weekly

What Makes Gibbs’ Cycle Different from Other Reflection Models?

Gibbs’ cycle stands out through its:

Distinct features:

Explicit focus on feelings
Separation of evaluation and analysis
Clear action planning stage

How Do I Know if My Reflections Are Deep Enough?

Quality reflection shows specific characteristics. Key indicators include:

Strong reflections:

Move beyond simple description
Consider multiple perspectives
Link to theory and research
Lead to specific improvements
Show clear learning outcomes

How Can I Use Gibbs’ Cycle for Team Reflection?

Team reflection benefits from structured approaches.

Effective team reflection:

Uses shared language and understanding
Provides clear structure for discussions
Supports collaborative learning
Leads to consistent practice improvements

What Common Mistakes Should I Avoid When Using the Cycle?

Practitioners often encounter similar challenges. Gibbs (1988) highlights key areas to watch:

Avoid:

Mixing description with analysis
Skipping the feelings stage
Creating vague action plans
Rushing through stages
Forgetting to implement changes

How Can I Make Sure My Reflections Lead to Real Changes?

Effective reflection leads to practice improvements…

Focus on implementation:

Create specific, measurable action plans
Set realistic timeframes
Review and revise regularly
Document changes in practice
Share learning with colleagues

References

Atkins, S., & Murphy, K. (1993). Reflection: A review of the literature. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 18(8), 1188-1192.
Benner, P. (1984). From novice to expert: Excellence and power in clinical nursing practice. Reading, NIA: Addison-Wesley
Boud D, Keogh R & Walker D (1985). Reflection Turning Experience into Learning. Kegan Page, London
Champion R. (1991). Educational accountability–what ho the 1990s! Nurse Educ Today. 11(6):407-14.
Chesney, M. (1996). Sharing reflections on critical incidents in midwifery practice. British Journal of Midwifery, 4(1), 8-11.
Cheyne, H., McGinley, M., & Turnbull, D. (1996). Peer review: An aid to reflective practice. MIDIRS Midwifery Digest March, 6(1), 4-6.
Gibbs, G. (1988). Learning by doing: A guide to teaching and learning methods. Further Education Unit, Oxford Polytechnic.
Haddock, J. (1997). Reflection in groups: Contextual and theoretical considerations within nurse education and practice. Nurse Education Today, 17(5), 381-385.
Jackson, D. (1999). Developing student reflection: A placement learning strategy. British Journal of Midwifery, 7(3), 177-180.
Janis, I. L. (1991). Groupthink. In E. Griffin (Ed.), A First Look at Communication Theory (pp. 235-246). McGraw-Hill.
Jones, P. (2000). Practical aspects of reflective practice in health care. Journal of Advanced Nursing Practice, 15(2), 45-52.
Parbold, T. (1998). Professional development through reflection. Nursing Times, 94(12), 221-226.
Rich, A., & Parker, D. L. (1995). Reflection and critical incident analysis: Ethical and moral implications of their use within nursing and midwifery education. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 22(6), 1050-1057.
Schön, D. A. (1991). The Reflective Practitioner: How professionals think in action. Temple Smith.
Stuart, C. C. (1998). Concepts of reflection and reflective practice. British Journal of Midwifery, 6(10), 640-647.
Thomas, R. (2003). Blending qualitative and quantitative research methods in theses and dissertations. Corwin Press.